Premier League clubs have voted to cover legal expenses for the organisation’s five board directors if any of Manchester City’s sponsors sue them, in a move that could expose all clubs to hundreds of millions of pounds of legal costs. The clubs met in London on Thursday for the first time since City were found guilty of a catalogue of charges relating to the breaching of financial rules by an independent commission in September.
Why it matters
City have appealed and maintain their innocence, with a sanction yet to be decided. The club’s sponsors Etihad and Etisalat have both said they are considering legal action against the Premier League. At present, under the league’s articles of association, a director is only financially covered should they win a legal case brought against them by a third party.
The new rules will extend legal indemnity for CEO Richard Masters, chair Alison Brittan and three other non-executive directors. City and Nottingham Forest were the only two clubs that voted against the proposal, with the other 18 voting in favour. Due to collective responsibility, all clubs are now liable to cover legal costs that could run into hundreds of millions of pounds.
The move raises the intriguing possibility of City being financially impacted by the legal action of its own sponsors, with the club’s fate hanging not on the commission’s verdict but on the willingness of companies that bankrolled it to take the league to court.
What happens next
It is understood City’s CFO Ingo Bank asked Premier League chair Alison Brittan during Thursday’s meeting whether the proposal was a direct result of threats of legal action from Etihad and Etisalat, but she said she could not comment. Forest have declined to comment, with their objection said to be on procedural grounds rather than support for City.
An independent commission appointed by the Premier League found City guilty of artificially inflating the club’s revenues by over £830m over a nine-year period in September, determining that the club arranged “sham” contracts with sponsors which disguised funding from club owners the Abu Dhabi United Group. Premier League CEO Richard Masters said City “systematically broke Premier League rules for nearly a decade”.
ADVERTISEMENT
Etihad Airways said it “categorically rejects any finding, conclusion or implication that suggests the airline has ever been involved in improper commercial arrangements”. Etisalat signalled its intention to follow suit earlier this month, describing the Premier League’s verdict as “entirely false and defamatory”.
A sanction for City has yet to be decided, following the club’s appeal against the commission’s findings. The clubs’ decision to share the legal costs was a break from the past, when directors were only covered if they won. The change means that, in the event of a legal challenge from Etihad or Etisalat, the full financial weight of the 20 clubs could be brought to bear.
The legal indemnity change is expected to be formalised after the meeting, with the Premier League confirming that the five directors will be covered in the event of a legal challenge. City’s appeal continues, and the outcome will be closely watched by other clubs. Clubs that opposed the proposal said they had raised concerns about the principle of collective responsibility, but agreed to table the change after negotiations.



























We do not allow links of any sort in comments. No SPAM whatsoever. On topic comments only.