Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh is set to decide the future of Britain’s largest untapped oil field, Rosebank, off Shetland, after the Court of Session left the previous government’s approval open to legal challenge. Ed Miliband has said he will “definitely not” resign if the project is approved, despite previously calling the scheme “climate vandalism”, citing collective responsibility as a member of the government.
Why it matters
The decision is a defining test of the Labour government’s climate and energy record. Rosebank is Britain’s largest untapped oil field and would also produce some gas; it lies about 80 miles north-west of Shetland and could fill up to 500 million barrels of oil over a 25-year lifetime. Approval would be welcomed by the Conservatives, who argue the country needs to “get Britain drilling”, but it is expected to be criticised by environmentalists, who say it would hamper efforts to tackle climate change and have no meaningful impact on the UK’s energy security or bills. The UK is committed to reaching net zero by 2050, meaning it must cut carbon emissions until it removes as much as it produces, and the ruling has forced the government to revisit a licence first granted in 2023 that was subsequently ruled unlawful by the Court of Session in Edinburgh.
The economic case
Supporters of the field point to the tax revenue and jobs it would generate, and argue that domestic production helps reduce the UK’s reliance on imported oil and gas at a time of global volatility. The project has also been presented as a way of using remaining North Sea infrastructure and the skills of the workforce in the region. Opponents counter that even fully developed, the field would have only a limited effect on household bills and that the long-term economic case is undermined by the need to leave much of the world’s oil reserves unburned if climate targets are to be met.
What happens next
Miatta Fahnbulleh will make the decision after a quasi-judicial assessment of all the evidence, and she will not have her approach second-guessed by her predecessor, who raised concerns about the project while Labour was in opposition. The result could trigger a rebellion among Labour MPs, with around 75 of them reported to have signed a letter opposing the project. If approved, drilling could begin swiftly, though the UK’s commitment to net zero and the international oil market mean the benefits are not guaranteed. A refusal would leave the North Sea industry and its skilled workers to question the government’s energy security strategy, while campaigners would claim a win for the climate. The government’s recent green light to the nearby Jackdaw gas field, whose gas began flowing earlier this month, complicates its position further.
The governing tension
Shadow energy secretary Andrew Bowie has argued that the approval of Rosebank undermines the party’s credibility on energy, warning that “one gas field does not make an energy strategy”. The dispute has put the government in a difficult position, balancing its climate ambitions with the political reality of the North Sea workforce and the cost of living. The final decision will be closely watched across the UK’s energy sector and will shape the debate over fossil fuel development for years to come.


























We do not allow links of any sort in comments. No SPAM whatsoever. On topic comments only.