Eleanor Donaldson has applied to appeal the verdict from her trial of the facts, with the Northern Ireland Courts Service confirming on Thursday that an application for leave to appeal had been lodged with the Court of Appeal by her legal team.
A trial on different terms
Donaldson faced a trial of the facts after being found unfit for a conventional criminal trial on mental health grounds. The proceedings ran alongside the trial of her husband, former Democratic Unionist Party leader Jeffrey Donaldson, at Newry Crown Court in May and June.
The trial of the facts is a legal mechanism used when a defendant is not well enough to stand trial in the ordinary way. It establishes whether the defendant did the acts alleged, without determining criminal guilt, because a person who is unfit cannot be convicted or sentenced in the normal sense. The outcome can lead to a treatment order or an absolute discharge, but not a prison sentence.
The court at Newry found that Donaldson had done the acts in relation to all five charges she faced. Four of those charges were of aiding and abetting the offending committed by her husband. Jeffrey Donaldson was convicted of 18 counts of sex abuse, including one count of rape, which he committed against two women when they were children.
What the appeal is about
An appeal against a trial of the facts verdict is not the same as a conventional criminal appeal. The Court of Appeal will first have to decide whether to grant leave to appeal, and the judge from the original trial is due to make a decision on the case in October. The Northern Ireland Courts Service said the application had been received, but it did not release further detail about the grounds on which Donaldson’s lawyers are challenging the outcome.
Jeffrey Donaldson’s solicitor has separately said he intends to appeal against his own convictions. That process is at an earlier stage and is separate from his wife’s application.
ADVERTISEMENT
Why it matters
The Donaldson case has been one of the most politically charged criminal trials in Northern Ireland in recent years. Jeffrey Donaldson was, at the time of his conviction, the leader of the largest party in the Northern Ireland Assembly and a long-standing figure in British and Irish politics. His conviction, and the way the case was handled, has had repercussions well beyond the courtroom.
Eleanor Donaldson’s position has always been different from her husband’s, both legally and because of the mental health finding that led to the trial of the facts rather than a full criminal trial. Her appeal is a routine but significant stage in that process, and it keeps the legal fallout from the case in the news as both defendants pursue separate routes through the courts.
What happens next
The Court of Appeal will consider the application for leave to appeal in due course. If leave is granted, the case will proceed to a fuller hearing. If it is refused, the trial of the facts verdict will stand. The judge from the original trial is expected to make a decision on the case in October, and that decision may shape what happens next in the appeal.
Jeffrey Donaldson’s own appeal against conviction is running on a separate track, and further developments in both cases are likely in the weeks ahead.
We do not allow links of any sort in comments. No SPAM whatsoever. On topic comments only.